Depression and sadness are often used interchangeably by patients: "I felt sad and depressed after that setback at work." While this phrasing might work in casual conversation, these experiences are actually quite distinct. Understanding this difference is crucial for both recognizing and addressing what you're experiencing.
What is Sadness?
Sadness is a natural emotion with three key components:
Cognitive awareness ("I am sad")
Physical sensations (heaviness in the chest, tears)
An inherent impulse to reach out and resolve what's causing the sadness
What is Depression?
Depression, from a psychodynamic perspective, is actually a defense against emotion. It manifests through:
Loss of motivation and energy
Feelings of hopelessness
Difficulty focusing
Disrupted sleep, appetite, and sex drive
A key distinguishing factor: Sadness comes in waves, lasting minutes or hours before passing. Depression tends to settle in and stay for extended periods. While sadness can temporarily reduce energy (unlike anger, which is activating), this similarity can make it easy to confuse the two experiences.
Understanding Fusion
When someone confuses a feeling for their defense against that feeling, we call this "fusion." It's particularly common among people who use repression as their primary psychological defense. Let's look at how this works using Malan's Triangle of Conflict:
A Real-World Example
Consider someone passed over for a promotion. When asked about their feelings, they sigh (showing anxiety) and respond, "I felt tired and slept for days. Quite sad really." This response combines the actual emotion with the defense against it - they're fused together.
Why This Matters
If you've fused sadness and depression, you might believe that experiencing emotions will worsen your situation. However, the emotion isn't the problem - it's the defense against it (depression) that creates difficulties. By separating these experiences and allowing natural emotional expression rather than defending against it, feelings can rise and fall naturally, helping restore your emotional equilibrium.
Ready to Learn More?
If you're struggling to understand your emotional experiences or find yourself caught in patterns of depression, I can help. I specialize in Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP), an evidence-based approach that helps people work through emotional defenses and experience lasting change.
Click here to check availability and schedule your first appointment.